Compare
PaystubLine vs ThePayStubs
PaystubLine differs from ThePayStubs in three ways: the price is on the button before you start, the stub previews live, and YTD carries across a batch of up to six pay dates. It also includes free paycheck calculators for every state.
Updated 2026-10-02 · 2026 tax year
| Feature | ThePayStubs | PaystubLine |
|---|---|---|
| Pay stub price shown before checkout | No price on the home page or stub form | $3.99, or $29 for the whole year |
| W-2 price | $19.99 | $7.99, or included with a Year Pass |
| Live preview while typing | Preview after entering details | Yes, on every keystroke |
| YTD across multiple stubs | Entered per stub | Carried automatically |
| Free paycheck calculators | No | 51 state calculators and salary tools |
| Trustpilot rating | 3.9 from 1,688 reviews | New |
ThePayStubs details are taken from its public website and review profiles as of 2026-10-02 and may have changed. ThePayStubs is a trademark of its owner; PaystubLine is not affiliated with it.